Integration and Reconstruction of the Terminology System for Citation Breaches

Zhang Qilin, Yang Linglong

Knowledge Management Forum ›› 2025, Vol. 10 ›› Issue (6) : 494-503.

PDF(2128 KB)
PDF(2128 KB)
Knowledge Management Forum ›› 2025, Vol. 10 ›› Issue (6) : 494-503. DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.2095-5472.2025.033  CSTR: 32306.14.CN11-6036.2025.033

Integration and Reconstruction of the Terminology System for Citation Breaches

Author information +
History +

Abstract

[Purpose/Significance] In response to the persistent ambiguity and conflation of terminology surrounding citation breaches in academic discourse, this study aims to propose a conceptual analytical framework for the classification and definition of citation breach terms, in order to promote research integrity in China and strengthen academic norms. [Method/Process] By systematically reviewing academic literature and policy documents from both domestic and international sources, the article extracts definitional features and usage contexts of citation breach terms. It constructs a dual-dimensional classification framework based on "research misconduct/questionable research practices" and "increase citation count/decrease citation count/no impact on citation count", alongside a three-element conceptual framework comprising "motivation–process–utility". [Result/Conclusion] Grounded in this framework, the article integrates and reconstructs the terminology system for citation breaches, establishing 11 primary core terms—honorary citation, excessive citation, citation contamination, referencing error, unintentional citation omission, citation bias, citation copying, citation misrepresentation, citation manipulation, concealed citation, fabricated citation—and clarifies the characteristics of each term across the dimensions of motivation, process, and utility. This provides a more operational tool for future institutional governance.

Key words

citation breaches / citation norm / academic norm / research integrity

Cite this article

Download Citations
Zhang Qilin , Yang Linglong. Integration and Reconstruction of the Terminology System for Citation Breaches[J]. Knowledge Management Forum. 2025, 10(6): 494-503 https://doi.org/10.13266/j.issn.2095-5472.2025.033

References

[1]
SZALANSKI C J, BEACH L R. The citation bias: fad and fashion in the judgment and decision literature[J]. American psychologist, 1984, 39(1): 75.
[2]
GARFIELD E, WELLJAMS-DOROF A. Citation data: their use as quantitative indicators for science and technology evaluation and policy-making[J]. Science and public policy, 1992, 19(5): 321-327.
[3]
KOSTOFF R N. The use and misuse of citation analysis in research evaluation[J]. Scientometrics, 1998, 43(1): 27-43.
[4]
FRANCK G. Scientific communication: a vanity fair?[J]. Science, 1999, 286(5437): 53-55.
[5]
BALL P. Paper trail reveals references go unread by citing authors[J]. Nature, 2002, 420(6916): 594.
[6]
GINSBURG I. The disregard syndrome: a menace to honest science?[J]. The scientist, 2001, 15(24): 51-52.
[7]
NOORDEN V R. Brazilian citation scheme outed[J]. Nature, 2013, 500(7464): 510-511.
[8]
BIAGIOLI M. Watch out for cheats in citation game[J]. Nature, 2016, 535(7611): 201.
[9]
NOORDEN V R, CHAWLA D S. Hundreds of extreme self-citing scientists revealed in new database[J]. Nature, 2019, 572(7771): 578-580.
[10]
ANDERSON R. Citation contamination: references to predatory journals in the legitimate scientific literature[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2019/10/28/citation-contamination-references-to-predatory-journals-in-the-legitimate-scientific-literature/.
[11]
杨昌勇.学术论著注释和索引的规范与功能[J]. 中国社会科学, 2002(2): 194-204.
YANG C Y. Formatting norm and function of notes and indexes in academic works[J]. Social sciences in China, 2002(2): 194‑204.
[12]
苏广利, 许新军.社科论著参考文献引用中的七种不良行为[J]. 图书馆工作与研究, 2002(2): 15-17.
SU G L, XU X J. Seven misconducts in the citation of references in social science works[J]. Library work and study, 2002(2): 15-17.
[13]
熊春茹.参考文献自引评价指标的探讨[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2002, 13(6): 514-515.
XIONG C R. Discussion on the evaluation index of self-citation in references[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2002, 13(6): 514-515.
[14]
任俊为.引文的异化与科学精神[J]. 情报资料工作, 2004(5): 26-27.
REN J W. Alienation of citations and the spirit of science[J]. Information and documentation services, 2004(5): 26-27.
[15]
叶继元.学术规范通论[M]. 上海:华东师范大学出版社, 2005:173-176.
YE J Y. General theory of academic norms[M]. Shanghai: East China Normal University Press, 2005:173-176.
[16]
赵伯兴.论引文行为中非道德风险的防范与规避[J]. 情报科学, 2005(6): 849-852.
ZHAO B X. On the prevention and avoidance of non-moral risks in citation behavior[J]. Information science, 2005(6): 849-852.
[17]
郭玲, 陈燕.参考文献著录中的学术道德缺失现象及其防范[J]. 编辑学报, 2007, (01): 8-10.
GUO L, CHEN Y. Phenomena of academic ethics deficiency in reference compilation and its prevention[J]. Acta editologica, 2007(1): 8-10.
[18]
常思敏.参考文献引用中的学术不端行为分析[J]. 出版科学, 2007(5): 23-25.
CHANG S M. Analysis of academic misconduct in reference citation[J]. Publishing science, 2007(5): 23-25.
[19]
陶范.学术论著应杜绝无效引用[J]. 编辑学报, 2007(3): 173-175.
TAO F. Learned publications should stop ineffective citing[J]. Acta editologica, 2007(3): 173-175.
[20]
朱大明.如何抑制无效引用[J]. 科技导报, 2008, 26(23): 105.
ZHU D M. How to suppress invalid citations[J]. Science & technology review, 2008, 26(23): 105.
[21]
赵贤瑶. 引文失范问题及其防治对策研究[J]. 科技管理研究, 2010, 30(23): 257-260.
ZHAO X Y. Research on the problem of citation irregularities and its countermeasures[J]. Science and technology management research, 2010, 30(23): 257-260.
[22]
赖方忠.引文失范研究[J]. 四川警察学院学报, 2013, 25(4): 134-140.
LAI F Z. Research on citation anomie[J]. Journal of Sichuan Police College, 2013, 25(4): 134-140.
[23]
闻浩, 鲁立.引用矮化——论参考文献的不当引用[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2013, 24(6): 1129-1131.
WEN H, LU L. Citation dwarfing: on improper citation of references[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2013, 24(6): 1129-1131.
[24]
刘应竹.学术论文中的引文失范问题刍议[J]. 编辑学报, 2014, 26(1): 7-9.
LIU Y Z. Citation anomie in academic papers[J]. Acta editologica, 2014, 26(1): 7-9.
[25]
万丽华, 王雅敏.高校论文引用奖励政策的负效应及对策研究[J]. 科学管理研究, 2016, 34(5): 44-47.
WAN L H, WANG Y M. The study of university's paper reference reward policy and it's coping strategies[J]. Science and technology management research, 2016, 34(5): 44-47.
[26]
邓履翔, 王维朗, 陈灿华.欺诈引用——一种新的不当引用行为[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2018, 29(3): 237-241.
DENG L X, WANG W L, CHEN C H. Fraudulent citation: a new improper citation behavior[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2018, 29(3): 237-241.
[27]
王志标.学术期刊论文引用失范表现、原因及治理[J]. 中国出版, 2020(21): 46-50.
WANG Z B. Manifestations, causes and governance of citation irregularities in academic journal papers[J]. China publishing journal, 2020(21): 46-50.
[28]
刘运梅, 李冉, 盛小平.隐形三角引用:科学论文中的不规范引用行为[J]. 现代情报, 2024, 44(4): 127-141.
LIU Y M, LI R, SHENG X P. Invisible triangle citation: an irregular citations in scientific papers[J]. Journal of modern information, 2024, 44(4): 127-141.
[29]
COPE. Guidance: citation manipulation[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://publicationethics.org/guidance/discussion-document/citation-manipulation.
[30]
ALLEA. The European code of conduct for research integrity[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://allea.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/European-Code-of-Conduct-Revised-Edition-2023.pdf.
[31]
CSE. Recommendations for promoting integrity in scientific journal publications[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://www.councilscienceeditors.org/recommendations-for-promoting-integrity-in-scientific-journal-publications.
[32]
CLARIVATE. Journal Citation Reports Reference Guide[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://clarivate.com/academia-government/lp/journal-citation-reports-reference-guide/.
[33]
SAGE. Publication ethics policies: citation manipulation policy[EB/OL]. [2025-11-15]. https://www.sagepub.com/journals/publication-ethics-policies/citation-manipulation-policy.

张麒麟:框架搭建,文献搜集,论文撰写;

羊灵龙:文献搜集,论文修订。

Funding

National Social Science Fund Youth Project titled "Research on the Governance of Citation Breaches under the Background of Research Integrity Construction"(23CTQ020)
PDF(2128 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/