
网络交易中的逆向选择及其规避措施研究
Research on Adverse Selection and Evasion Strategies in Online Transactions
[目的/意义]对网络交易中的逆向选择问题进行系统分析,为缓解网络交易中的信息不对称问题提供理论依据,以期提升网络交易市场效率,推动电子商务产业健康持续发展。[方法/过程]在界定网络交易中逆向选择概念的基础上,分析逆向选择的主要表现,运用文献研究和专家调查法探讨逆向选择的形成原因,并提出相应的规避措施。[结果/结论]网络交易中逆向选择与道德风险问题划分标志被明确;网络交易中逆向选择问题主要表现在所购商品物非所值、商品配送时效降低及商品破损风险增加;逆向选择形成原因包括商品文本型描述信息缺失和虚假、商品图片型描述信息失真、消费者评论信息不真实不全面、电子商务平台评价数据不可靠、经验商品性能无法通过信息分辨、商家配货信息虚假和缺失、客服传递过程中的信息偏差、物流服务信息不具体、物流流转信息不准确,影响力依次递减。
[Purpose/Significance] A systematic analysis of adverse selection in online transactions is conducted to provide a theoretical basis for mitigating information asymmetry in online transactions, with a view to enhancing the efficiency of the online transaction market and promoting the healthy and sustainable growth of the e-commerce industry. [Method/Process] On the basis of defining the concept of adverse selection in online transactions, the article discussed the main performances, used literature research and expert survey methods to explore the causes of adverse selection, and proposed corresponding evasion solutions. [Result/Conclusion] The division between adverse selection and moral hazard problems in online transactions is clarified. The adverse selection in online transactions is mostly represented in the non-value of acquired products, a decrease in commodity distribution timeliness, and an increase in the danger of commodity damage. The formation reasons of adverse selection include missing and false information on text-based descriptions of goods, distorted information on picture-based descriptions of goods, untrue and incomplete information on consumer reviews, unreliable evaluation data on e-commerce platforms, empirical goods performance cannot be discerned through information, false and missing information on merchants' dispensing, information bias in the process of customer service delivery, unspecific information on logistics services, and inaccurate information on logistics flow, with all the factors' influence decreases in order.
逆向选择 / 信息不对称 / 网络交易 / 形成原因 / 规避策略
adverse selection / information asymmetry / online transaction / formation causes / evasion strategies
[1] |
国家统计局.2022年国民经济和社会发展统计公报[R/OL].[2023-11-08].http://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/zxfb/202302/t20230228_1919011.html.(National Bureau of Statistics of China. Statistical communique on the 2022 national economic and social development[R/OL].[2023-04-20].http://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/zxfb/202302/t20230228_1919011.html.)
|
[2] |
徐晨,蒋艳楠.线上购物信息不对称与顾客购买意向相关性分析:基于感知风险视角[J].商业经济研究, 2021(11): 85-88.(XU C, JIANG Y N. Analysis of the correlation between online shopping information asymmetry and customer’s purchasing intention: based on the perspective of perceived risk[J].Journal of commercial economics, 2021(11): 85-88.)
|
[3] |
潘勇.浅论网络交易中的逆向选择问题[J].情报学报, 2002(6): 751-755.(PAN Y. Research on the adverse selection in the e-marketing[J]. Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information, 2002(6): 751-755.)
|
[4] |
潘勇.逆向选择与中国电子商务市场声誉机制的本土性研究——以淘宝网为例[J].商业经济与管理, 2012(1): 13-18.(PAN Y. Adverse selection and local research on the reputation mechanism in e-commerce market in China:a case study of Taobao.com[J].Journal of business economics, 2012(1): 13-18.)
|
[5] |
桂学文,杨俊.电子商务市场中的“柠檬问题”及其解决途径[J].情报杂志,2004(9):72-74.(GUI X W, YANG J. “Lemon problem” in e-commerce market and its solution[J].Journal of intelligence,2004(9):72-74.)
|
[6] |
LEE B, YOO B. What prevents electronic lemon markets?[J]. Journal of organizational computing and electronic commerce, 2007,17(3): 217-246.
|
[7] |
王健聪.基于博弈视角的电子商务“柠檬”问题研究[J].统计与决策, 2012(20): 72-74.(WANG J C. Analysis of the “Lemon problem” in e-commerce market:based on the perspective of game theory[J].Statistics & decision, 2012(20): 72-74.)
|
[8] |
TIWANA A, BUSH A A. Spotting lemons in platform markets: a conjoint experiment on signaling[J]. IEEE transactions on engineering management, 2014,61(3): 393-405.
|
[9] |
刘杰.网络购物环境下逆向选择行为治理研究[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨商业大学,2020.(LIU J. Study on the governance of adverse selection behavior under network shopping environment[D]. Harbin: Harbin University of Commerce,2020.)
|
[10] |
AKERLOF G. The market for “Lemons”:quality uncertainty and the market mechanism[J]. The quarterly journal of economics, 1970, 84(3): 488-500.
|
[11] |
ARROW K. Uncertainty and the welfare economics of medical care[J]. The American economic review, 1963, 53(5): 941-973.
|
[12] |
艾媒咨询.2022-2023年中国快递物流行业市场创新与标杆企业运营模式研究报告-智慧物流行业研究报告[R/OL].[2023-07-19].https://report.iimedia.cn/repo10-0/43272.html.(iiMedia Research. Research report on marketing innovation and operation mode of benchmarking companies in China's express logistics industry from 2022 to 2023[R/OL].[2023-03-19].https://report.iimedia.cn/repo10-0/43272.html. )
|
[13] |
张璇.电子商务信息不对称与网络购物风险分析[J].商业经济研究, 2017(2): 84-86.(ZHANG X. Research on the information asymmetry and risk in online shopping[J].Journal of commercial economics, 2017(2): 84-86.)
|
[14] |
王海燕,蔡欣然,宁升.农村电商平台交易信息不对称困境及规避对策研究[J].情报科学, 2020,38(11): 128-133.(WANG H Y, CAI X R, NING S. Research on the dilemma and countermeasures of asymmetric transaction information on rural e-commerce platforms[J].Information science, 2020,38(11): 128-133.)
|
[15] |
昝梦莹,王征兵.农产品电商直播:电商扶贫新模式[J].农业经济问题, 2020(11): 77-86.(ZAN M Y, WANG Z B. E-commerce live streaming of agricultural products:a new mode of poverty alleviation[J].Issues in agricultural economy, 2020(11): 77-86.)
|
[16] |
WANG N X, LIANG H G, XUE Y J, et al. Mitigating information asymmetry to achieve crowdfunding success:signaling and online communication[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 2021,22(3):773-796.
|
[17] |
张文,王强,马振中,等.在线商品虚假评论发布动机及形成机理研究[J].中国管理科学, 2022,30(7): 176-188.(ZHANG W, WANG Q, MA Z Z, et al. Research on the motivation and formation mechanism of online products deceptive reviews[J].Chinese journal of management science, 2022,30(7): 176-188.)
|
[18] |
邓佳欣,傅智能.自媒体时代对电子商务信息不对称的影响分析[J].广西质量监督导报, 2019(2): 107-109.(DENG J X, FU Z N. Analysis of the information asymmetry in e-commerce market in the era of we-media[J]. Guangxi quality supervision guide periodical, 2019(2): 107-109.)
|
[19] |
SHEN C C, CHIOU J S, KUO B S. Remedies for information asymmetry in online transaction an investigation into the impact of web page signals on auction outcome[J]. Internet research, 2011, 21(2): 154-170.
|
[20] |
VECCHIO R, PARGA-DANS E, GONZALEZ P A, et al. Why consumers drink natural wine? consumer perception and information about natural wine[J]. Agricultural and food economics, 2021,9(1): 22.
|
[21] |
刘向明.解析电子商务中的信息不对称问题[J].湖南科技学院学报, 2016, 37(1): 123-124.(LIU X M. Analysis of the information asymmetry in e-commerce market[J].Journal of Hunan University of Science and Engineering, 2016, 37(1): 123-124.)
|
[22] |
李朝辉,周声海,万国华.大型跨境消费电子品供应链的补货管理和库存优化[J].系统管理学报, 2022,31(6): 1075-1083.(LI Z H, ZHOU S H, WAN G H. Replenishment management and inventory optimization in a large international consumer electronics supply chain[J]. Journal of systems & management, 2022,31(6): 1075-1083.)
|
[23] |
张劢书,包欢乐.电子商务信息不对称研究——以淘宝网为例[J].电脑知识与技术, 2017,13(33): 277-278.(ZHANG M S, BAO H L. Analysis of the information asymmetry in e-commerce market:a case study of Taobao.com[J]. Computer knowledge and technology, 2017,13(33): 277-278.)
|
[24] |
魏际刚.中国物流业发展的现状、问题与趋势[J].北京交通大学学报(社会科学版), 2019,18(1):1-9.(WEI J G. China’s logistics industry: its current situation,problem and future trend[J]. Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University(social sciences edition), 2019,18(1): 1-9.)
|
[25] |
叶楚琪.物流上市企业社交媒体信息披露活动研究——以顺丰控股为例[J].物流技术, 2021,40(4): 36-39.(YE C Q. Research on social media information disclosure of listed logistics companies:taking SF Holdings as example[J]. Logistics technology, 2021,40(4): 36-39.)
|
[26] |
梁雯,司俊芳.基于共享经济的“区块链+物流”创新耦合发展研究[J].上海对外经贸大学学报, 2019, 26(1): 60-69.(LIANG W, SI J F. Research on innovative coupling development of “blockchain +logistics”:based on shared economy[J]. Journal of Shanghai University of International Business and Economics, 2019,26(1):60-69.)
|
[27] |
景娥. 区块链背景下农产品流通模式演化动力机制与创新[J].商业经济研究, 2020(23):125-128.(JING E. The dynamic evolution mechanism and innovation of circulation pattern of agricultural product based on blockchain[J]. Journal of commercial economics, 2020(23):125-128.)
|
[28] |
王春枝,斯琴.德尔菲法中的数据统计处理方法及其应用研究[J].内蒙古财经学院学报(综合版), 2011,9(4):92-96.(WANG C Z, SI Q. A study of data statistical processing method of Delphi method and its application[J].Journal of Inner Mongolia University of finance and economics, 2011,9(4):92-96.)
|
[29] |
江彦,娄策群,江秀,等.评论者对在线商品评论信息质量的影响及提升策略研究[J].图书馆学研究, 2019(3): 78-83. (JIANG Y, LOU C Q, JIANG X, et al. Research on the impact of commentators on the online commodity review information quality and promotion strategy[J]. Research on library science, 2019(3): 78-83.)
|
[30] |
HUI X, SAEEDI M, SUNDARESAN N. Adverse selection or moral hazard, an empirical study[J]. Journal of industrial economics, 2018,66(3): 610-649.
|
樊悦:撰写与修改论文;
娄策群:进行论文框架设计,修改论文;
桂学文:提出论文修改意见。
/
〈 |
|
〉 |